| 1) Illinois Wesleyan | 3:53.49 (05/01) | 3:49.35 (05/08) | 3:49.99 (04/22) | 3:50.18 (05/15) | 3:55.08 (04/18) | 3:57.55 (04/04) | 4:04.77 (04/11) |
| 2) Nazareth | 3:53.49 (05/01) | 3:56.40 (05/14) | 3:56.86 (05/08) | 4:01.36 (04/11) | 4:03.87 (04/19) | 4:07.69 (04/02) | 4:08.72 (03/27) |