| 1) | Giglio, Juan | TCNJ | 4.50m (04/24-04/25) | 4.50m (05/08) | 4.40m (04/11) | 4.35m (05/08) | 4.35m (04/24-04/25) | 4.34m (05/11) | 4.25m (04/17-04/18) | 4.25m (04/11) |
| 2) | Ravnaas, Samuel | MIT | 4.50m (04/30-05/02) | 4.45m (04/25) | 4.45m (04/18) | 4.35m (04/30-05/02) | 4.30m (04/25) | 4.30m (04/18) | 4.20m (04/30-05/02) | 4.15m (04/04) |
| 3) | Anderson, Garrett | Bates | 4.50m (04/18) | 4.45m (04/11-04/12) | 4.40m (04/18) | 4.30m (04/18) | 4.15m (04/18) | 4.00m (04/18) | 4.00m (04/25) | |
| 4) | Kollmer, Charles | Cortland St. | 4.50m (05/01-05/02) | 4.40m (04/10-04/11) | 4.35m (03/27-03/28) | 4.35m (05/01-05/02) | 4.30m (04/03-04/04) | 4.25m (04/10-04/11) | 4.20m (04/17-04/18) | 4.15m (04/03-04/04) |