| 1) | Groll, Matti | Boston U. | 3:50.46 (01/30) | 3:50.46 (01/30) | 3:51.89 (05/01-05/02) | 3:53.79 (05/07-05/09) | 3:55.71 (03/27-03/28) | 3:56.53 (01/22) | 3:56.53 (01/22) | 3:57.60 (04/11) |
| 2) | Ubriaco, Otis | Iona | 3:50.46 (05/11) | 3:56.17 (05/02-05/03) | 4:02.42 (04/11) | 4:10.18 (03/27-03/28) |