| 1) | O'Toole, Garrett | Princeton | 3:48.85 (02/28) | 3:48.85 (02/28) | 3:50.09 (02/14) | 3:50.09 (02/14) | 3:52.78 (02/28) | 3:52.78 (02/28) | ||
| 2) | Gregory, Patrick | Dartmouth | 3:48.85 (05/16) | 3:49.83 (04/17-04/18) | 3:51.54 (04/11) | 3:52.41 (05/09-05/10) | 3:54.69 (02/13) | 3:54.69 (02/13) | 4:03.88 (02/28) | 4:03.88 (02/28) |