| 1) | Roach, Cooper | Canisius | 3:49.83 (02/21) | 3:49.83 (02/21) | 3:49.83 (02/21) | 3:52.26 (05/02-05/03) | 3:56.59 (02/06) | 3:56.59 (02/06) | 3:59.65 (04/11) | 4:05.18 (01/09) |
| 2) | Nestor, Daniel | Columbia | 3:49.83 (02/13) | 3:49.83 (02/13) | 3:50.27 (04/11) | 3:53.82 (02/28) | 3:53.82 (02/28) | 3:54.59 (04/03-04/04) | 3:54.81 (01/24) | 3:54.81 (01/24) |