| 1) | Szogi, Istvan | Southern Utah | 14:27.10 (02/12-02/13) | 14:27.10 (02/12-02/13) | 15:40.57 (02/25-02/27) | 15:40.57 (02/25-02/27) | ||
| 2) | Maton, Marc | SE Missouri | 14:28.91 (02/13) | 14:28.91 (02/13) | 15:12.15 (02/26-02/27) | 15:12.15 (02/26-02/27) | ||
| 3) | Kemp, Barrett | Buffalo | 14:38.07 (01/29) | 14:38.07 (01/29) | 14:46.09 (02/26-02/27) | 14:46.09 (02/26-02/27) | 14:48.67 (02/12-02/13) | 14:48.67 (02/12-02/13) |
| 4) | Munns, Matthew | Georgia Tech | 15:02.50 (01/29-01/30) | 15:02.50 (01/29-01/30) | ||||
| 5) | Gilligan, Brian | MIT | 15:15.97 (12/05) | 15:15.97 (12/05) | 15:24.80 (02/19-02/20) | 15:24.80 (02/19-02/20) | 15:27.84 (02/06) | 15:27.84 (02/06) |
| 6) | Markham, Christopher | Stephen F. Austin | 15:36.45 (01/15-01/16) | 15:36.45 (01/15-01/16) | ||||
| 7) | Porter, Samuel | Western Kentucky | 16:49.19 (12/05) | 16:49.19 (12/05) |