| 1) | Coffey, Joe | St. Olaf | 3:46.18 (04/21-04/22) | 3:46.18 (04/21-04/22) | 3:48.83 (05/26-05/28) | 3:48.83 (05/26-05/28) | 3:50.91 (05/26-05/28) | 3:50.91 (05/26-05/28) | 3:54.64 (04/09) | 3:54.64 (04/09) |
| 2) | Dickerson, Sam | Missouri | 3:49.82 (03/25-03/26) | 3:49.82 (03/25-03/26) | 3:59.57 (04/22-04/23) | 3:59.57 (04/22-04/23) |