| 1) | Connell, Dawson | William and Mary | 3:46.40 (04/22-04/23) | 3:46.40 (04/22-04/23) | 3:47.26 (05/06-05/07) | 3:47.26 (05/06-05/07) | 3:47.88 (03/31-04/02) | 3:47.88 (03/31-04/02) | 3:53.49 (04/15-04/16) | 3:53.49 (04/15-04/16) |
| 2) | Geberkidane, Cerake | Oklahoma State | 3:50.06 (03/25-03/26) | 3:50.06 (03/25-03/26) | 3:50.23 (05/01) | 3:50.23 (05/01) | ||||
| 3) | Hoover, Caleb | Northern Arizona | 3:50.06 (03/19) | 3:50.06 (03/19) | ||||||
| 4) | Streich, Shane | Minnesota | 3:52.36 (04/01-04/02) | 3:52.36 (04/01-04/02) | ||||||
| 5) | Boseman, Alex | UNC-Wilmington | 4:11.05 (03/05) | 4:11.05 (03/05) |