| 1) | Makins, Jordan | Penn State | 3:46.68 (04/16-04/17) | 3:46.68 (04/16-04/17) | 3:48.96 (03/31-04/02) | 3:48.96 (03/31-04/02) | ||||
| 2) | Kamau, Bryan | Georgia | 3:48.52 (04/08-04/09) | 3:48.52 (04/08-04/09) | 3:49.03 (04/22-04/23) | 3:49.03 (04/22-04/23) | 3:49.83 (04/14-04/16) | 3:49.83 (04/14-04/16) | 3:50.93 (05/12-05/14) | 3:50.93 (05/12-05/14) |
| 3) | Muhammad, Kendall | Kentucky | 3:50.53 (03/31-04/02) | 3:50.53 (03/31-04/02) | 3:51.07 (03/18-03/19) | 3:51.07 (03/18-03/19) | 3:52.48 (04/22-04/23) | 3:52.48 (04/22-04/23) | ||
| 4) | Galli, Steven | Texas A&M-CC | 3:52.45 (03/24-03/26) | 3:52.45 (03/24-03/26) | 3:53.73 (04/16) | 3:53.73 (04/16) | 3:59.90 (05/06-05/08) | 3:59.90 (05/06-05/08) | 4:00.43 (04/23) | 4:00.43 (04/23) |
| 5) | Roberts, Ian | Arizona State | 3:52.45 (03/18-03/19) | 3:52.45 (03/18-03/19) | ||||||
| 6) | Tucker, Ryan | George Washington | 3:53.10 (03/26) | 3:53.10 (03/26) | 3:56.73 (04/09) | 3:56.73 (04/09) | 3:57.11 (04/22-04/23) | 3:57.11 (04/22-04/23) |