| 1) | Baldwin, Alec | Black Hills St. | 3:46.75 (04/27-04/30) | 3:46.75 (04/27-04/30) | 3:54.12 (05/06-05/08) | 3:54.12 (05/06-05/08) | 3:54.14 (05/26-05/28) | 3:54.14 (05/26-05/28) | 3:56.42 (05/06-05/08) | 3:56.42 (05/06-05/08) |
| 2) | Patel, Nepolian | Wingate | 3:48.76 (03/17-03/19) | 3:48.76 (03/17-03/19) | 3:49.09 (04/22-04/23) | 3:49.09 (04/22-04/23) | 3:51.67 (04/15-04/16) | 3:51.67 (04/15-04/16) | 3:58.77 (05/26-05/28) | 3:58.77 (05/26-05/28) |
| 3) | Espino, George | Southern Utah | 3:49.34 (04/09) | 3:49.34 (04/09) | 4:06.73 (03/17-03/19) | 4:06.73 (03/17-03/19) | ||||
| 4) | Olmos, Alvaro | Tennessee-Martin | 3:51.50 (03/25-03/26) | 3:51.50 (03/25-03/26) | 3:58.83 (04/08-04/09) | 3:58.83 (04/08-04/09) | ||||
| 5) | Farris, Christian | Texas A&M | 3:52.46 (03/18-03/19) | 3:52.46 (03/18-03/19) | 3:56.08 (04/30) | 3:56.08 (04/30) | ||||
| 6) | Johnson, Michael | Montevallo | 4:07.62 (03/05) | 4:07.62 (03/05) | 4:08.60 (04/21-04/23) | 4:08.60 (04/21-04/23) | 4:09.17 (03/18-03/19) | 4:09.17 (03/18-03/19) | 4:09.17 (03/18-03/19) | 4:09.17 (03/18-03/19) |