| 1) | Caruthers, Brigette | Central Arkansas | 5:25.36 (03/18-03/19) | 5:25.36 (03/18-03/19) |
| 2) | Pineda, Michelle | Cal St. San B'dino | 5:27.18 (03/11-03/12) | 5:27.18 (03/11-03/12) |
| 3) | Wise, Samantha | UMass Lowell | 5:32.58 (03/26) | 5:32.58 (03/26) |
| 4) | Downum, Sierra | Sonoma St. | 5:39.92 (04/01-04/02) | 5:39.92 (04/01-04/02) |