| 1) | Hassett, Heather | Hartford | 5:26.02 (04/02) | 5:26.02 (04/02) |
| 2) | Blumel, Rachel | Weber State | 5:27.45 (04/21-04/23) | 5:27.45 (04/21-04/23) |
| 3) | Topham, Abigail | Central Arkansas | 5:28.50 (03/18-03/19) | 5:28.50 (03/18-03/19) |
| 4) | Fogelsanger, Kasey | York (Pa.) | 5:30.64 (03/19) | 5:30.64 (03/19) |
| 5) | Fuelling, Meghan | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | 5:33.27 (02/20) | 5:33.27 (02/20) |
| 6) | Robles, Xochitl | Cal Poly Pomona | 5:40.64 (03/11-03/12) | 5:40.64 (03/11-03/12) |
| 7) | Webb, Baylee | Mississippi College | 5:46.22 (03/18-03/19) | 5:46.22 (03/18-03/19) |