| 1) | Casillas, Alyssa | Cal St. San B'dino | 5:26.24 (03/11-03/12) | 5:26.24 (03/11-03/12) |
| 2) | Cuffe, Dara | Providence | 5:27.50 (04/15-04/16) | 5:27.50 (04/15-04/16) |
| 3) | Tuszkiewicz, Heidi | Campbell | 5:28.61 (03/12) | 5:28.61 (03/12) |
| 4) | Demick, Stasia | Pepperdine | 5:30.87 (03/11-03/12) | 5:30.87 (03/11-03/12) |
| 5) | Keohane, Kerri | Holy Cross | 5:33.37 (04/02) | 5:33.37 (04/02) |
| 6) | Lombardo, Elizabeth | Holy Cross | 5:40.74 (04/02) | 5:40.74 (04/02) |