| 1) | Sandoval, Julian | Whittier | 4:26.87 (02/20) | 4:26.87 (02/20) |
| 2) | Cummings, Chris | Clemson | 4:27.98 (03/17-03/19) | 4:27.98 (03/17-03/19) |
| 3) | Polich, Seth | UC-Colo. Spgs. | 4:33.98 (03/26) | 4:33.98 (03/26) |
| 4) | Eltringham, Christopher | Mount St. Mary's | 4:46.00 (03/17-03/19) | 4:46.00 (03/17-03/19) |