| 1) | Mannion, Tyler | Quinnipiac | 4:26.94 (04/02) | 4:26.94 (04/02) |
| 2) | Gronostaj, Kyle | Albany | 4:28.16 (03/17-03/19) | 4:28.16 (03/17-03/19) |
| 3) | Sumerford, Luke | UNC-Greensboro | 4:30.29 (03/12) | 4:30.29 (03/12) |
| 4) | Mensher, Matthew | Quinnipiac | 4:31.82 (04/02) | 4:31.82 (04/02) |
| 5) | Kleist, Jakob | Azusa Pacific | 4:31.82 (03/11-03/12) | 4:31.82 (03/11-03/12) |
| 6) | Erickson, Andrew | York (Pa.) | 4:34.17 (03/19) | 4:34.17 (03/19) |