| 1) | Nong, Randy | UMass Lowell | 4:26.98 (03/17-03/19) | 4:26.98 (03/17-03/19) |
| 2) | Dell, Grant | York (Pa.) | 4:28.18 (03/19) | 4:28.18 (03/19) |
| 3) | Arsenault, Matthew | UMass Lowell | 4:30.32 (03/26) | 4:30.32 (03/26) |
| 4) | Shaw, Matthew | Stonehill | 4:34.19 (03/26) | 4:34.19 (03/26) |
| 5) | Johnston, Joel | UNC Pembroke | 4:34.19 (03/18-03/19) | 4:34.19 (03/18-03/19) |
| 6) | Darnall, Sam | Mississippi College | 4:46.45 (03/18-03/19) | 4:46.45 (03/18-03/19) |