| 1) | Greenhalgh, Connor | Eastern Kentucky | 4:27.26 (05/07) | 4:27.26 (05/07) | ||
| 2) | Nifong, Zachary | UNC-Wilmington | 4:28.44 (03/12) | 4:28.44 (03/12) | 4:29.26 (03/17-03/19) | 4:29.26 (03/17-03/19) |
| 3) | Nazarek, Cristian | Humboldt State | 4:30.35 (04/22-04/23) | 4:30.35 (04/22-04/23) | ||
| 4) | Kahovec, Timmy | Cal Lutheran | 4:32.11 (02/20) | 4:32.11 (02/20) | ||
| 5) | Anderson, Danyon | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | 4:34.71 (02/20) | 4:34.71 (02/20) | ||
| 6) | Matthiesen, Zach | Principia | 4:37.54 (03/18-03/19) | 4:37.54 (03/18-03/19) | ||
| 7) | Guzman, Kyle | UMass Amherst | 4:39.76 (04/02) | 4:39.76 (04/02) | ||
| 8) | Glover, Chad | UC-Colo. Spgs. | 4:46.52 (03/26) | 4:46.52 (03/26) |