| 1) | Helminski, Christopher | Hartford | 4:27.37 (03/26) | 4:27.37 (03/26) |
| 2) | Gielarowski, Derek | Detroit | 4:28.62 (04/26) | 4:28.62 (04/26) |
| 3) | Cunningham, Jamie | Citadel | 4:30.42 (03/17-03/19) | 4:30.42 (03/17-03/19) |
| 4) | Chimal-Rodriguez, Angel | Immaculata | 4:32.26 (03/19) | 4:32.26 (03/19) |
| 5) | Moroney, Ben | Trevecca Nazarene | 4:34.76 (03/18-03/19) | 4:34.76 (03/18-03/19) |
| 6) | Allen, Anthony | Maryville (Mo.) | 4:37.78 (03/18-03/19) | 4:37.78 (03/18-03/19) |
| 7) | Fransham, Nick | Mount St. Mary's | 4:41.68 (03/17-03/19) | 4:41.68 (03/17-03/19) |