| 1) | Gonzales, Jarrett | UCLA | 52.89 (04/16) | 52.89 (04/16) | 52.94 (05/01) | 52.94 (05/01) | 53.55 (05/07) | 53.55 (05/07) | 54.30 (03/22) | 54.30 (03/22) |
| 2) | McGetrick, Ian | BYU | 52.89 (05/12-05/13) | 52.89 (05/12-05/13) | 53.11 (04/29-04/30) | 53.11 (04/29-04/30) | 53.30 (04/01) | 53.30 (04/01) | 53.38 (04/08-04/09) | 53.38 (04/08-04/09) |
| 3) | Johnson, Parker | Dartmouth | 52.95 (04/22-04/23) | 52.95 (04/22-04/23) | 53.61 (05/07-05/08) | 53.61 (05/07-05/08) | 53.73 (03/25-03/26) | 53.73 (03/25-03/26) | 53.87 (04/16) | 53.87 (04/16) |
| 4) | Williams, Kordell | Navy | 53.89 (04/02) | 53.89 (04/02) | 54.31 (04/22-04/23) | 54.31 (04/22-04/23) | ||||
| 5) | Peeples, Jamil | Arkansas State | 54.16 (03/25-03/26) | 54.16 (03/25-03/26) | 54.49 (05/13-05/15) | 54.49 (05/13-05/15) | 55.13 (03/17-03/18) | 55.13 (03/17-03/18) | 56.45 (04/29-04/30) | 56.45 (04/29-04/30) |