| 1) Chadron State | 3:47.67 (04/23) | 3:47.67 (04/23) | 3:47.81 (05/06) | 3:47.81 (05/06) | 3:48.35 (04/14) | 3:48.35 (04/14) | 3:54.23 (04/01) | 3:54.23 (04/01) |
| 2) P.R.-Rio Piedras | 3:48.85 (04/14) | 3:48.85 (04/14) | 3:54.61 (02/26) | 3:54.61 (02/26) | 3:54.63 (03/05) | 3:54.63 (03/05) | 4:03.20 (04/28) | 4:03.20 (04/28) |
| 3) Paine | 3:57.09 (03/12) | 3:57.09 (03/12) | 3:57.25 (04/14) | 3:57.25 (04/14) | 4:04.06 (03/30) | 4:04.06 (03/30) | 4:08.62 (04/02) | 4:08.62 (04/02) |
| 4) Edward Waters | 4:02.53 (03/12) | 4:09.52 (02/27) | 4:09.82 (04/08) | 4:12.06 (04/23) | 4:20.78 (02/27) | |||
| 5) North Georgia | 4:11.58 (03/12) | 4:11.58 (03/12) |