| 1) Case Western | 7:53.00 (04/23) | 7:53.00 (04/23) | 8:12.61 (03/18) | 8:12.61 (03/18) | 8:31.17 (03/18) | 8:31.17 (03/18) |
| 2) Nebraska-Kearney | 8:04.16 (04/02) | 8:04.16 (04/02) | ||||
| 3) Charleston (W.V.) | 8:08.18 (03/25) | 8:08.18 (03/25) | 8:52.85 (03/25) | 8:52.85 (03/25) | 9:12.43 (03/04) | 9:12.43 (03/04) |
| 4) Olivet | 9:07.26 (03/26) | 9:07.26 (03/26) |