| 1) Saint Francis (Pa.) | 7:54.05 (05/07) | 7:54.05 (05/07) | ||
| 2) Tennessee Wesleyan | 8:04.60 (04/22) | 8:09.11 (03/18) | ||
| 3) Millikin | 8:29.03 (03/31) | 8:29.03 (03/31) | ||
| 4) Tuskegee | 8:50.83 (03/25) | 8:50.83 (03/25) | 9:07.38 (02/28) | 9:07.38 (02/28) |
| 5) SUNYIT | 9:13.67 (03/26) | 9:13.67 (03/26) | 9:20.34 (04/16) | 9:20.34 (04/16) |