| 1) | Ballenger, Jared | Ohio State | 53.57m (04/09) | 53.55m (04/09) | 53.55m (04/09) | 53.50m (04/09) | 53.50m (04/09) | 53.18m (05/13-05/15) | 53.18m (05/13-05/15) | 53.18m (05/13-05/15) |
| 2) | Yeastedt, Tyler | RPI | 53.57m (04/16) | 52.21m (05/26-05/28) | 52.21m (05/26-05/28) | 52.21m (05/26-05/28) | 52.21m (05/26-05/28) | 51.94m (04/30) | 51.94m (04/30) | 51.94m (04/30) |