| 1) | Hamilton, Grant | Air Force | 57.13m (05/11-05/14) | 57.03m (05/11-05/14) | 57.03m (05/11-05/14) | 55.68m (05/06) | 55.68m (05/06) | 55.43m (05/06) | 55.43m (05/06) | 54.58m (05/11-05/14) |
| 2) | Dozier, Marcus | DePauw | 57.13m (04/16) | 56.52m (04/16) | 56.52m (04/16) | 56.14m (04/16) | 56.14m (04/16) | 53.73m (04/22) | 53.73m (04/22) | 53.73m (04/22) |
| 3) | Ragonesi, Gian | Miami | 57.13m (04/08-04/09) | 56.46m (04/08-04/09) | 56.46m (04/08-04/09) | 56.10m (03/25) | 56.10m (03/25) | 55.83m (05/13-05/15) | 55.83m (05/13-05/15) | 55.83m (05/13-05/15) |