| 1) | Munson, Dom | Rutgers | 3:52.44 (04/22-04/23) | 3:52.83 (04/15-04/16) | 3:55.94 (02/04) | 3:56.89 (02/12) | 3:58.49 (03/31-04/02) | 3:58.87 (01/22) | 4:01.09 (05/13-05/15) | 4:05.11 (01/08) |
| 2) | Berger, Sam | Princeton | 3:52.44 (04/22-04/23) | 3:54.65 (01/29) | 3:56.86 (01/09) | 3:59.36 (04/15-04/16) |