| 1) | Martin, Avery | Va. Military Institute | 3:47.35 (02/19) | 3:48.15 (04/22-04/23) | 3:51.39 (02/05) | 3:52.22 (02/26) | 3:54.51 (05/12-05/13) | 3:58.48 (03/04) | 3:58.53 (02/26) | 4:01.43 (01/15) |
| 2) | Lampron, Josh | Villanova | 3:47.35 (04/22-04/23) | 3:54.83 (05/13-05/14) | 3:56.38 (05/13-05/14) | 3:58.08 (12/05) | 4:08.82 (01/08) |