| 1) | Arredondo, Julio | Central Connecticut | 2:29.46 (01/27-01/28) | 2:29.46 (01/27-01/28) | 2:30.38 (02/24-02/25) | 2:30.38 (02/24-02/25) | 2:31.84 (02/24-02/25) | 2:31.84 (02/24-02/25) | 2:33.13 (01/14) | 2:33.13 (01/14) |
| 2) | Musselman, Brent | Virginia Tech | 2:29.46 (02/17-02/18) | 2:29.46 (02/17-02/18) | ||||||
| 3) | Yoonis, Adel | Kansas | 2:29.46 (01/26-01/27) | 2:29.46 (01/26-01/27) |