| 1) | Chavis, Brenden | Mount St. Mary's | 18.32m (03/03-03/05) | 18.28m (03/03-03/05) | 18.28m (03/03-03/05) | 18.26m (02/17-02/18) | 18.26m (02/17-02/18) | 18.26m (02/17-02/18) | 18.26m (02/17-02/18) | 17.99m (01/27-01/28) |
| 2) | Shumate, Lucas | Ohio Northern | 18.32m (02/24-02/25) | 18.14m (02/17) | 18.14m (02/17) | 18.14m (02/17) | 18.14m (02/17) | 18.11m (01/28) | 18.11m (01/28) | 18.11m (01/28) |
| 3) | Hogan, Austin | Indianapolis | 18.32m (02/25-02/26) | 18.13m (02/10) | 18.13m (02/10) | 18.13m (02/10) | 18.13m (02/10) | 18.12m (02/17) | 18.12m (02/17) | 18.12m (02/17) |
| 4) | Camp, Ryan | TCU | 18.32m (01/21) | 17.96m (02/10) | 17.96m (02/10) | 17.96m (02/10) | 17.96m (02/10) | 17.93m (02/10) | 17.93m (02/10) | 17.92m (02/03-02/04) |