| 1) | Roberts, Casey | Wartburg | 1:54.89 (03/03-03/04) | 1:56.21 (02/18) | 1:58.64 (01/26-01/27) | 1:59.03 (02/24-02/25) | |||
| 2) | Baehl, Hayden | Wabash | 1:54.89 (03/03-03/04) | 1:56.23 (02/17) | 1:57.48 (01/28) | 1:57.67 (02/04) | 1:58.26 (01/21) | 1:59.20 (03/03-03/04) | 2:00.23 (12/03) |