| 1) | Rydell, Eric | Illinois Wesleyan | 2.02m (02/17) | 1.99m (02/11) | 1.98m (12/03) | 1.97m (02/17) | 1.95m (02/24-02/25) | 1.95m (01/21) | 1.94m (02/11) | 1.93m (02/04) |
| 2) | Bailey, Tevin | Stevenson | 2.02m (02/24-02/25) | 1.99m (02/24-02/25) | 1.96m (02/18) | 1.96m (02/24-02/25) | 1.93m (01/14) | 1.93m (01/21) | 1.93m (02/24-02/25) | 1.91m (02/18) |
| 3) | Shrieves, Wesley | Christopher Newport | 2.02m (02/18) | 1.99m (02/18) | 1.96m (02/18) | 1.95m (01/13) | 1.93m (02/18) | 1.90m (01/20-01/21) | 1.90m (02/18) | 1.90m (01/13) |
| 4) | Keck, Nathan | Wartburg | 2.02m (02/03-02/04) | 1.97m (02/11) | 1.97m (03/03-03/04) | 1.97m (02/18) | 1.97m (02/03-02/04) | 1.93m (01/26-01/27) | 1.92m (02/03-02/04) | 1.92m (02/18) |
| 5) | Morris, Malik | Nebraska Wesleyan | 2.02m (02/24-02/25) | 1.97m (02/24-02/25) | 1.92m (02/24-02/25) | 1.87m (02/24-02/25) |