| 1) | Natalone, John | Middlebury | 4.55m (01/27-01/28) | 4.55m (02/17-02/18) | 4.55m (02/24-02/25) | 4.40m (02/17-02/18) | 4.40m (02/24-02/25) | 4.40m (01/27-01/28) | 4.28m (01/14) | 4.25m (01/27-01/28) |
| 2) | McCracken, Andrew | Wesleyan | 4.55m (02/17-02/18) | 4.55m (02/04) | 4.40m (02/17-02/18) | 4.35m (02/04) | 4.28m (01/21) | 4.25m (01/14) | 4.25m (02/17-02/18) | 4.25m (02/04) |
| 3) | Frick, Michael | Coast Guard | 4.55m (02/24-02/25) | 4.40m (02/24-02/25) | 4.40m (02/17-02/18) | 4.25m (02/10-02/11) | 4.25m (02/17-02/18) | 4.10m (01/14) | 4.10m (02/10-02/11) | 3.95m (02/10-02/11) |