| 1) | Campbell, Drew | Wittenberg | 1.90m (02/18) | 1.89m (03/03) | 1.88m (05/05-05/06) | 1.86m (12/03) | 1.85m (02/04) | 1.84m (03/24-03/25) | 1.84m (03/03) | 1.83m (01/21) |
| 2) | Crocker, Reed | Kenyon | 1.90m (02/18) | 1.85m (02/18) | 1.85m (04/22) | 1.81m (04/07-04/08) | 1.80m (04/22) | 1.80m (02/18) | 1.78m (04/28) | 1.78m (04/15) |
| 3) | Fraley, Nick | Ohio Wesleyan | 1.90m (12/03) | 1.85m (12/03) | 1.83m (02/04) | 1.80m (12/03) | 1.77m (02/18) | 1.75m (12/03) | 1.74m (02/04) | 1.71m (02/04) |