| 1) | Freyholtz, Josh | Wis.-Stout | 4.91m (04/08) | 4.90m (05/05-05/06) | 4.78m (04/29) | 4.76m (04/08) | 4.75m (05/05-05/06) | 4.63m (04/29) | 4.62m (04/20-04/21) | 4.62m (04/13-04/14) |
| 2) | Steinman, Josh | Brockport St. | 4.91m (05/17-05/18) | 4.88m (04/09) | 4.81m (05/17-05/18) | 4.76m (05/17-05/18) | 4.75m (04/29) | 4.71m (04/09) | 4.70m (04/02) | 4.70m (05/05-05/06) |
| 3) | Evansen, Wes | Wis.-La Crosse | 4.91m (04/08) | 4.83m (05/18) | 4.77m (04/13-04/14) | 4.76m (04/08) | 4.75m (05/05-05/06) | 4.68m (05/18) | 4.68m (05/12) | 4.63m (04/29) |