| 1) | Nixon, Daniel | Miss State | 1:50.01 (04/07-04/08) | 1:50.11 (03/30-04/01) | 1:51.04 (04/22) | 1:53.06 (05/11-05/13) |
| 2) | McDevitt, Billy | Penn State | 1:50.01 (04/21-04/22) | 1:50.97 (05/12-05/14) | ||
| 3) | Rono, Hillary | Mid. Tenn. State | 1:50.01 (04/21-04/22) | 1:52.62 (03/31-04/01) | 1:54.58 (05/11-05/14) |