| 1) | Hammonds, Cody | Houston Baptist | 1:51.24 (04/22) | 1:51.70 (03/23-03/25) | 1:52.59 (04/13-04/15) | 1:53.73 (05/12-05/14) | 1:54.99 (03/30-04/01) | 2:08.97 (05/12-05/14) |
| 2) | Simpson, De'Vion | UT-Arlington | 1:51.24 (05/12-05/14) | 1:51.86 (05/12-05/14) | 1:51.98 (04/08) | 1:52.25 (05/03) | 1:53.00 (04/14-04/15) | 1:54.11 (03/25) |
| 3) | Uhr, Robert | Texas | 1:51.24 (05/05) | 1:52.52 (04/28-04/29) | 2:00.87 (03/29-04/01) |