| 1) | Bailey, Tevin | Stevenson | 1.99m (03/25) | 1.99m (05/17-05/18) | 1.95m (04/14) | 1.94m (03/25) | 1.94m (05/17-05/18) | 1.93m (05/04-05/06) | 1.90m (05/04-05/06) | 1.90m (04/14) |
| 2) | Stone, Dereck | Westfield State | 1.99m (04/15) | 1.98m (04/29) | 1.94m (04/15) | 1.93m (04/22) | 1.93m (04/29) | 1.89m (04/15) | 1.88m (04/29) | 1.88m (04/22) |
| 3) | Jimenez, Johan | Medgar Evers | 1.99m (05/17-05/18) | 1.95m (03/31-04/01) | 1.94m (05/17-05/18) | 1.93m (03/25) | 1.90m (05/14) | 1.90m (04/08) | 1.89m (05/17-05/18) | 1.85m (04/08) |
| 4) | Olugbenga, Olutobi | Misericordia | 1.99m (05/17-05/18) | 1.94m (05/17-05/18) | 1.93m (05/04-05/06) | 1.92m (04/22) | 1.90m (03/31-04/01) | 1.90m (05/04-05/06) | 1.90m (04/12) | 1.89m (05/17-05/18) |