| 1) | Jackson, Dashaun | Saint Francis (Pa.) | 14.10 (03/30-04/01) | 14.10 (03/30-04/01) | 14.14 (04/27-04/29) | 14.14 (04/27-04/29) | 14.29 (04/27-04/29) | 14.29 (04/27-04/29) | 14.30 (05/06-05/07) | 14.30 (05/06-05/07) |
| 2) | Fontaine, Micah | Air Force | 14.10 (05/25-05/27) | 14.10 (05/25-05/27) | 14.18 (05/10-05/13) | 14.18 (05/10-05/13) | 14.27 (05/10-05/13) | 14.27 (05/10-05/13) | 14.49 (04/22) | 14.49 (04/22) |
| 3) | Siedhoff, Luke | Nebraska | 14.10 (05/12-05/14) | 14.10 (05/12-05/14) | 14.20 (05/06) | 14.20 (05/06) | ||||
| 4) | Brixey, Sam | Washington St. | 14.10 (03/31-04/01) | 14.10 (03/31-04/01) | 14.37 (03/17-03/18) | 14.37 (04/13-04/15) | 14.37 (03/17-03/18) | 14.37 (04/13-04/15) | 14.47 (04/23) | 14.47 (04/23) |
| 5) | Phillips, Rhys | Baylor | 14.10 (03/17-03/18) | 14.10 (03/17-03/18) | 14.65 (03/29-04/01) | 14.65 (03/29-04/01) |