| 1) | Smith, Darius | Colorado St. | 52.53 (05/10-05/13) | 52.53 (05/10-05/13) | 52.83 (05/05) | 52.83 (05/05) | 52.96 (05/10-05/13) | 52.96 (05/10-05/13) | 53.26 (03/25) | 53.26 (03/25) |
| 2) | Caveney, Sean | Davidson | 52.53 (05/06-05/07) | 52.53 (05/06-05/07) | 52.93 (05/06-05/07) | 52.93 (05/06-05/07) | 53.06 (04/21-04/22) | 53.06 (04/21-04/22) | 53.47 (04/08) | 53.47 (04/08) |
| 3) | Lambert, Kiyair | Delaware State | 52.53 (05/04-05/06) | 52.53 (05/04-05/06) | 53.52 (04/27-04/29) | 53.52 (04/27-04/29) | 53.68 (05/12) | 53.68 (05/12) | 53.95 (04/15) | 53.95 (04/15) |