| 1) | Gaston, Leah | Holy Family | 4.66m (12/01) | 4.61m (02/03) | 4.55m (12/01) | 4.52m (12/01) | 4.44m (01/12) | 4.34m (02/03) | 4.32m (02/03) | 4.29m (01/12) |
| 2) | Costanzo, Nicole | LIU Post | 4.66m (12/08) | 4.57m (01/13) | 4.54m (01/13) | 4.46m (01/13) | 4.46m (12/08) | 4.42m (01/19) | 4.41m (12/01) | 4.40m (12/08) |