| 1) | Wheatley, Jahkeem | Oberlin | 4.41m (03/02-03/03) | 4.27m (12/08-12/09) | 4.26m (03/02-03/03) | 4.25m (01/12) | 4.25m (01/27) | 4.15m (01/20) | 4.12m (12/08-12/09) | 4.11m (12/02) |
| 2) | Nemeth, Tyler | DePauw | 4.41m (03/02-03/03) | 4.26m (03/02-03/03) | 4.15m (02/02) | 4.11m (03/02-03/03) | 4.00m (02/02) | 3.96m (03/02-03/03) | 3.95m (02/17) | 3.94m (01/19) |