| Place | Name | Year | Team | Time | Score | Heat(Pl) | |
| 1. | Hammond, Michael | SO-2 | Virginia Tech | 4:03.80 | - | 1(1) | |
| 2. | Nanni, Cory | JR-3 | Duke | 4:05.17 | - | 1(2) | |
| 3. | mostrag, axel | SO-2 | VCU | 4:05.65 | - | 1(3) | |
| 4. | McDermott, Ryan | JR-3 | Duke | 4:05.68 | - | 1(4) | |
| 5. | Mulherin, William | SO-2 | Virginia Tech | 4:06.40 | - | 1(5) | |
| 6. | Waggoner, Bo | JR-3 | Duke | 4:06.84 | - | 1(6) | |
| 7. | Lund, Josh | JR-3 | Duke | 4:09.88 | - | 2(1) | |
| 8. | Hagen, Ryan | FR-1 | Virginia Tech | 4:12.63 | - | 1(7) | |
| 9. | Monds, Jevin | JR-3 | High Point | 4:13.18 | - | 1(8) | |
| 10. | Zyryanov, Alex | FR-1 | George Mason | 4:16.87 | - | 2(2) | |
| 11. | Reynolds, Robert | SO-2 | George Mason | 4:17.09 | - | 2(3) | |
| 12. | Flynn, Ricky | SR-4 | Lynchburg | 4:18.45 | - | 2(4) | |
| 13. | Smith, Jacob | FR-1 | High Point | 4:18.72 | - | 2(5) | |
| 14. | Harper, Chris | SO-2 | Georgia State | 4:19.52 | - | 2(6) | |
| 15. | kendall, justin | FR-1 | VCU | 4:20.44 | - | 2(7) | |
| 16. | Brodsky, Michael | SR-4 | Tennessee | 4:21.03 | - | 2(8) | |
| 17. | Van Alstine, Ryan | JR-3 | Lynchburg | 4:21.13 | - | 2(9) | |
| 18. | McGinn, Ian | FR-1 | Va. Military Institute | 4:24.47 | - | 3(1) | |
| 19. | Naro, Jeff | SR-4 | UNC-Wilmington | 4:25.03 | - | 3(2) | |
| 20. | Graham, Jake | FR-1 | Wake Forest | 4:26.97 | - | 3(3) | |
| 21. | Wunsch, Chris | FR-1 | Va. Military Institute | 4:27.91 | - | 3(4) | |
| 22. | Tamer, Remy | JR-3 | UNC-Wilmington | 4:28.28 | - | 3(5) | |
| 23. | Bailey, Matthew | SR-4 | George Mason | 4:29.32 | - | 3(6) | |
| 24. | Tipton, Spenser | FR-1 | Tennessee | 4:32.93 | - | 2(10) | |
| 25. | Monroe, Ross | JR-3 | UNC-Wilmington | 4:33.82 | - | 3(7) | |
| 26. | Sagar, Matt | SR-4 | Va. Military Institute | 4:34.41 | - | 3(8) | |
| 27. | McDaniel, Lance | SR-4 | Concord | 4:37.53 | - | 3(9) | |
| 28. | Adams, Eric | JR-3 | Radford | 4:41.31 | - | 3(10) | |
| 29. | Edmonds, Stuart | FR-1 | High Point | 4:42.87 | - | 3(11) | |
| 30. | Jackson , Jonathan | JR-3 | Johnson C. Smith | 4:42.97 | - | 3(12) | |
| 31. | Arocho, Liam | SR-4 | Radford | 4:43.53 | - | 3(13) | |
| 32. | Keltner, Sam | FR-1 | Radford | 4:49.56 | - | 3(14) | |
| 33. | King, Kent | FR-1 | Johnson C. Smith | 4:57.78 | - | 3(15) | |
| 34. | Ferguson, Brad | FR-1 | Concord | 4:59.77 | - | 3(16) | |
| Cusack, Jason | SO-2 | Virginia Tech | NT | - | 1 | ||
| Mannino, Carmelo | FR-1 | Tennessee | NT | - | 2 |