| 1. | 6. | | 1. | 5. | Roanoke | Case Western | Virginia-Lynchburg | Virginia-Lynchburg | Guilford | A | A | A | A | A | Devine Fenner, Tomas Newman, Damario Carroll, Bryan Moses | Karim Frazier, Darren Petty, Lamont Mohabir, Philemon Afrifa-Boakye | Max Doerwaldt, Jerrel Graham, Romaijn Williams, Steven Santiago | Devine Fenner, Tomas Newman, Damario Carroll, Bryan Moses | Kiandre Brown, Daniel Jarrell, Timothy Campbell-Fowler, Dymere Jones | 1744.494 | 641.642 | DNF | 641.642 | DNF |
| 5. | 2. | | 2. | 2. | Guilford | Case Western | Guilford | Roanoke | Mary Baldwin University | A | A | A | A | A | Dominic Oddo, Juan Perez, Jimmy Zassick, Musa Hakim Jr. | Devine Fenner, Tomas Newman, Damario Carroll, Bryan Moses | Max Doerwaldt, Jerrel Graham, Romaijn Williams, Steven Santiago | Troy Crawley, Grant Williams, Brandon Justice, Joey Reid | Troy Crawley, Grant Williams, Brandon Justice, Joey Reid | 641.642 | 43.6244 | 641.642 | 43.6244 | 1744.494 |
| 2. | 6. | 3. | 3. | | Guilford | Case Western | Case Western (B) | Guilford | Randolph | A | A | A | A | A | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | Max Doerwaldt, Jerrel Graham, Romaijn Williams, Steven Santiago | Juwan Houston, trevel alexander, Jeremiah Hedrick, Asa Bell | Karim Frazier, Darren Petty, Lamont Mohabir, Philemon Afrifa-Boakye | DNS | 44.2196 | 7146.4032 | 44.2196 | 641.642 |
| 6. | 5. | 1. | 4. | | Virginia-Lynchburg | Case Western (B) | Case Western (B) | Earlham | Earlham | A | A | A | A | A | Kiandre Brown, Daniel Jarrell, Timothy Campbell-Fowler, Dymere Jones | Troy Crawley, Grant Williams, Brandon Justice, Joey Reid | Devine Fenner, Tomas Newman, Damario Carroll, Bryan Moses | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | Jimmie Johnson, Donovan Fiore, Carter Huffman, Doug Dracon | 641.642 | 448.96 | 1744.494 | 1744.494 | 448.96 |
| | 4. | 3. | 5. | 5. | Davis & Elkins | Roanoke | Davis & Elkins | Mary Baldwin University | Randolph | A | A | A | A | A | Troy Crawley, Grant Williams, Brandon Justice, Joey Reid | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | Juwan Houston, trevel alexander, Jeremiah Hedrick, Asa Bell | Max Doerwaldt, Jerrel Graham, Romaijn Williams, Steven Santiago | Dominic Oddo, Juan Perez, Jimmy Zassick, Musa Hakim Jr. | 448.96 | 43.6244 | 1744.494 | 7146.4032 | 448.96 |
| 6. | | 6. | 6. | 1. | Case Western (B) | Guilford | Washington and Lee | Case Western (B) | Case Western | A | A | A | B | A | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | Jimmie Johnson, Donovan Fiore, Carter Huffman, Doug Dracon | Kiandre Brown, Daniel Jarrell, Timothy Campbell-Fowler, Dymere Jones | Jordan Butler, Mitchell Webb, Ananth Suresh, Andrew Zapor | Kiandre Brown, Daniel Jarrell, Timothy Campbell-Fowler, Dymere Jones | DNF | 7146.4032 | 7146.4032 | 448.96 | DQ |
| 3. | | 5. | | | Virginia-Lynchburg | Virginia-Lynchburg | Washington and Lee | Davis & Elkins | Virginia-Lynchburg | A | A | A | A | A | Karim Frazier, Darren Petty, Lamont Mohabir, Philemon Afrifa-Boakye | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | Jordan Butler, Mitchell Webb, Ananth Suresh, Andrew Zapor | Kiandre Brown, Daniel Jarrell, Timothy Campbell-Fowler, Dymere Jones | Karim Frazier, Darren Petty, Lamont Mohabir, Philemon Afrifa-Boakye | 44.2196 | 448.96 | DNF | DQ | 448.96 |
| | 3. | | | 1. | Guilford | Randolph | Washington and Lee | Case Western | Case Western | A | A | A | A | A | Devine Fenner, Tomas Newman, Damario Carroll, Bryan Moses | Jordan Butler, Mitchell Webb, Ananth Suresh, Andrew Zapor | Max Doerwaldt, Jerrel Graham, Romaijn Williams, Steven Santiago | Dominic Oddo, Juan Perez, Jimmy Zassick, Musa Hakim Jr. | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | DNF | 641.642 | 7146.4032 | DNF | DNF |
| 3. | 2. | 1. | | | Mary Baldwin University | Virginia-Lynchburg | Case Western | Randolph | Virginia-Lynchburg | A | A | A | A | A | Jordan Butler, Mitchell Webb, Ananth Suresh, Andrew Zapor | Troy Crawley, Grant Williams, Brandon Justice, Joey Reid | Kiandre Brown, Daniel Jarrell, Timothy Campbell-Fowler, Dymere Jones | Karim Frazier, Darren Petty, Lamont Mohabir, Philemon Afrifa-Boakye | Jimmie Johnson, Donovan Fiore, Carter Huffman, Doug Dracon | 1744.494 | DNS | 1744.494 | DNF | 43.6244 |
| 6. | 5. | 6. | | 4. | Roanoke | Earlham | Case Western | Washington and Lee | Washington and Lee | A | A | A | A | A | Troy Crawley, Grant Williams, Brandon Justice, Joey Reid | Kiandre Brown, Daniel Jarrell, Timothy Campbell-Fowler, Dymere Jones | Sheldan Lindsay, Jake Patton, Justin Kerobo, Drew FitzGibbon | Jimmie Johnson, Donovan Fiore, Carter Huffman, Doug Dracon | Jimmie Johnson, Donovan Fiore, Carter Huffman, Doug Dracon | 1744.494 | 1744.494 | 1744.494 | DNS | DNF |
