| 1. | 4. | 2. | 3. | 4. | St. John's | VCU | St. John's | St. John's | VCU | A | A | A | A | A | Avon Samuels, Skyy Diop, Brianna Burkley, Leah Anderson | Lauryn Freeman, Jailah Channer, Taylor James, Courtney Higgins | Karah Moore, Nia McMillan, Simone Pierre, Yasmine Silmon | Lauryn Freeman, Jailah Channer, Taylor James, Courtney Higgins | Eliza Brennan, Lauren Carter, Alexis Leech, Jill Paciga | 3:52.345 | 4:05.676 | 4:09.63 | 4:05.676 | 4:09.63 |
| 2. | 1. | 4. | 3. | 4. | VCU | VCU | St. John's | VCU | St. John's | A | A | A | A | A | Karah Moore, Nia McMillan, Simone Pierre, Yasmine Silmon | Karah Moore, Nia McMillan, Simone Pierre, Yasmine Silmon | Karah Moore, Nia McMillan, Simone Pierre, Yasmine Silmon | Avon Samuels, Skyy Diop, Brianna Burkley, Leah Anderson | Lauryn Freeman, Jailah Channer, Taylor James, Courtney Higgins | 3:57.95 | 3:57.95 | 4:09.63 | 3:57.95 | 3:52.345 |
| 3. | 1. | 4. | 1. | 4. | Pittsburgh | VCU | St. John's | VCU | St. John's | A | A | A | A | A | Eliza Brennan, Lauren Carter, Alexis Leech, Jill Paciga | Avon Samuels, Skyy Diop, Brianna Burkley, Leah Anderson | Avon Samuels, Skyy Diop, Brianna Burkley, Leah Anderson | Karah Moore, Nia McMillan, Simone Pierre, Yasmine Silmon | Lauryn Freeman, Jailah Channer, Taylor James, Courtney Higgins | 4:05.676 | 4:09.63 | 3:57.95 | 3:57.95 | 3:52.345 |
| 4. | 2. | 3. | 4. | 4. | VCU (B) | St. John's | St. John's | St. John's | VCU (B) | B | A | A | B | A | Lauryn Freeman, Jailah Channer, Taylor James, Courtney Higgins | Karah Moore, Nia McMillan, Simone Pierre, Yasmine Silmon | Lauryn Freeman, Jailah Channer, Taylor James, Courtney Higgins | Karah Moore, Nia McMillan, Simone Pierre, Yasmine Silmon | Avon Samuels, Skyy Diop, Brianna Burkley, Leah Anderson | 4:09.63 | 3:52.345 | 4:09.63 | 4:09.63 | 3:52.345 |
