| 4. | 1. | 2. | 2. | Wooster | Ohio Wesleyan | Ohio Wesleyan (B) | Denison | A | A | A | A | Charlie Webb, Millan Henegar, Lance Tobasky, Jacob Brown | Jacob Bauer, Levi Kilian, Kyler Brock, Justin Winfield | Charlie Webb, Millan Henegar, Lance Tobasky, Jacob Brown | Jacob Bauer, Levi Kilian, Kyler Brock, Justin Winfield | 9:03:55.122 | 59:03:26.3800 | 56:03:42.777 | 59:03:26.3800 | - | 513 | - | 30358 |
| 3. | 2. | 2. | 5. | Allegheny | Wooster | Allegheny | Allegheny | B | A | A | A | Jacob Bauer, Levi Kilian, Kyler Brock, Justin Winfield | Joe Shilts, Craig Akiri, Zachary Galdo, Nick Scherson | Joseph McAuliffe, Austin Shaw, Kevin Long, Liam McCann | Jacob Bauer, Levi Kilian, Kyler Brock, Justin Winfield | 56:03:42.777 | 3:33.8662 | 3:33.8662 | 56:03:42.777 | - | 30358 | 207 | - |
| 1. | 3. | 3. | 3. | Denison | Allegheny | Denison | Ohio Wesleyan | A | A | A | A | Joseph McAuliffe, Austin Shaw, Kevin Long, Liam McCann | Joseph McAuliffe, Austin Shaw, Kevin Long, Liam McCann | Joseph McAuliffe, Austin Shaw, Kevin Long, Liam McCann | Evan Miller, Clay Sturts, Andrew Gallogly, Ethan Bradt | 56:03:42.777 | 54:03:39.402 | 54:03:39.402 | 9:03:55.122 | 30358 | 207 | 207 | - |
| 1. | 4. | 1. | 3. | Ohio Wesleyan (B) | Denison | Ohio Wesleyan | Ohio Wesleyan | A | A | B | B | Jacob Bauer, Levi Kilian, Kyler Brock, Justin Winfield | Charlie Webb, Millan Henegar, Lance Tobasky, Jacob Brown | Joe Shilts, Craig Akiri, Zachary Galdo, Nick Scherson | Joseph McAuliffe, Austin Shaw, Kevin Long, Liam McCann | 3:33.8662 | 56:03:42.777 | 9:03:55.122 | 56:03:42.777 | 207 | - | - | - |
| 2. | 5. | 3. | 1. | Denison | Ohio Wesleyan (B) | Wooster | Allegheny | A | B | A | A | Jacob Bauer, Levi Kilian, Kyler Brock, Justin Winfield | Evan Miller, Clay Sturts, Andrew Gallogly, Ethan Bradt | Jacob Bauer, Levi Kilian, Kyler Brock, Justin Winfield | Charlie Webb, Millan Henegar, Lance Tobasky, Jacob Brown | 54:03:39.402 | 9:03:55.122 | 59:03:26.3800 | 9:03:55.122 | - | - | 513 | 30358 |
