| 1. | 3. | Duquesne | Carnegie Mellon | A | A | Collin Ebling, Jarrett Boyd, Shamus Keefe, Matthew Busche | Antoine Perpignand, Jordan McKenzie, Timothy Roberts, Destyn Harding | 15:03:23.8111 | 3:29.024 | 551094 | 6 |
| 2. | 3. | LIU | LIU | A | A | Antoine Perpignand, Jordan McKenzie, Timothy Roberts, Destyn Harding | Antoine Perpignand, Jordan McKenzie, Timothy Roberts, Destyn Harding | 3:25.5105 | 53:03:37.234 | 836 | - |
| 3. | 4. | Carnegie Mellon | Saint Francis University | A | A | Grant Johnson, Alex Ivanov, Graham Eversden, Andrew McGovern | Noah Ball, Nick Fetzer, Anthony Litrenta, Zack Toth | 3:27.208 | 3:27.208 | 6 | 6 |
| 4. | 3. | Mount St. Mary's | Duquesne (B) | A | A | Thomas Altman, Zach Berg, John McKinney, James Munlyn | Grant Johnson, Alex Ivanov, Graham Eversden, Andrew McGovern | 3:29.024 | 53:03:37.234 | 33530 | 551094 |
| 5. | 4. | Saint Francis University | Duquesne (B) | A | A | Matthew Berzonsky, Michael Gallagher, Tobias Jones, Ethan Knoebel | Noah Ball, Nick Fetzer, Anthony Litrenta, Zack Toth | 53:03:37.234 | 3:25.5105 | 06450 | 06450 |
| 6. | 1. | Duquesne (B) | LIU | B | A | Noah Ball, Nick Fetzer, Anthony Litrenta, Zack Toth | Matthew Berzonsky, Michael Gallagher, Tobias Jones, Ethan Knoebel | 3:37.539 | 53:03:37.234 | - | 6 |
