| 1) | Kidder, Brannon | Penn State | 3:40.11 (04/22) | 3:40.11 (04/22) | 3:40.67 (06/08-06/11) | 3:40.67 (06/08-06/11) | 3:43.29 (05/26-05/28) | 3:43.29 (05/26-05/28) | 3:43.46 (05/26-05/28) | 3:43.46 (05/26-05/28) |
| 2) | Prakel, Sam | Oregon | 3:40.11 (05/14-05/15) | 3:40.11 (05/14-05/15) | 3:40.84 (06/08-06/11) | 3:40.84 (05/01) | 3:40.84 (06/08-06/11) | 3:40.84 (05/01) | 3:40.93 (06/08-06/11) | 3:40.93 (06/08-06/11) |