| 1. | 10. | 12. | 13. | Penn State | St. Joseph's (Pa.) (B) | Robert Morris | St. Francis (Pa.) (B) | A | A | A | A | Emunael Mpanduki, Matt Gilmore, Bernard Bennett-Green, Aaron Nadolsky | Derek Henry, David Smith, Brendan Robert, Tyler Gallen | David Hightower, Michael Breen, Ron Moore, Matthew Millemann | Kevin Persson, Karl Desil, Robert Rogers, Jonathan Ocasio | 10:03:09.6508 | 3:34.6688 | 40:03:25.792 | 30:03:23.8550 |
| 2. | 6. | 13. | 3. | Pittsburgh | Penn State | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | Pittsburgh | A | B | A | A | Micah Murray, Jerome Lowery, Dontave Cowsette, Brycen Spratling | Malcolm Ayers, Chris Carper, R. Abraham Roy, Jermaine Dwight | Chris Fischer, Shaun Foley, Chris DeLaney, Tim Wertner | Chris Fischer, Shaun Foley, Chris DeLaney, Tim Wertner | 40:03:09.6802 | 3:19.869 | 40:03:25.792 | 45:03:23.02 |
| 3. | 11. | 4. | 11. | Penn State (B) | St. Peter's | St. Francis (Pa.) | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | B | A | A | B | Sancho Barrett, Ryan Brennan, Connor Manley | Wilvenson Baptiste, James Burroughs, Dave Brown, Daequan Kim | Anthony Rusonis, Cedric Forbes, Daniel Drozdowsky, Ryan DuBois | Anthony Rusonis, Cedric Forbes, Daniel Drozdowsky, Ryan DuBois | 2:03:17.94 | 23:03:41.3682 | 40:03:25.792 | 2:03:17.94 |
| 4. | 13. | 9. | 11. | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | St. Peter's | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | A | A | B | A | Derek Henry, David Smith, Brendan Robert, Tyler Gallen | Micah Murray, Jerome Lowery, Dontave Cowsette, Brycen Spratling | Sancho Barrett, Ryan Brennan, Connor Manley | Nathan Sweeley, Paul Stults, Caleb Getty, Richard Smith | 3:19.27 | 3:19.869 | 23:03:41.3682 | 30:03:23.8550 |
| 5. | 10. | 8. | 13. | St. Peter's | St. Francis (Pa.) | UMBC | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | A | A | B | A | Kevin Persson, Karl Desil, Robert Rogers, Jonathan Ocasio | Emunael Mpanduki, Matt Gilmore, Bernard Bennett-Green, Aaron Nadolsky | David Hightower, Michael Breen, Ron Moore, Matthew Millemann | Malcolm Ayers, Chris Carper, R. Abraham Roy, Jermaine Dwight | 3:19.869 | 40:03:09.6802 | 3:19.869 | 45:03:23.02 |
| 6. | 4. | 12. | 12. | St. Joseph's (Pa.) (B) | Robert Morris | Penn State (B) | Penn State (B) | B | A | A | A | Tyler Dougherty, Griffith Roberts, Matt McGarvey, Jon Eisemann | Malte Bertram, Eric Ezenwanne, John Rybak, Joshua Hewitson | Micah Murray, Jerome Lowery, Dontave Cowsette, Brycen Spratling | David Hightower, Michael Breen, Ron Moore, Matthew Millemann | 10:03:21.852 | 10:03:09.6508 | 45:03:23.02 | 40:03:09.6802 |
| 7. | 11. | 13. | 1. | UMBC | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | Rider (B) | Rider | A | B | A | B | Malte Bertram, Eric Ezenwanne, John Rybak, Joshua Hewitson | Emunael Mpanduki, Matt Gilmore, Bernard Bennett-Green, Aaron Nadolsky | Anthony Rusonis, Cedric Forbes, Daniel Drozdowsky, Ryan DuBois | Malte Bertram, Eric Ezenwanne, John Rybak, Joshua Hewitson | 3:22.2649 | 3:19.869 | 10:03:21.852 | 45:03:23.02 |
| 8. | 1. | 2. | 3. | Rider (B) | Rider (B) | St. Peter's | UMBC | B | A | A | A | David Hightower, Michael Breen, Ron Moore, Matthew Millemann | Malte Bertram, Eric Ezenwanne, John Rybak, Joshua Hewitson | Kevin Persson, Karl Desil, Robert Rogers, Jonathan Ocasio | Kevin Persson, Karl Desil, Robert Rogers, Jonathan Ocasio | 45:03:23.02 | 45:03:23.02 | 23:03:41.3682 | 40:03:09.6802 |
| 9. | 5. | 11. | 13. | Robert Morris | St. Peter's | Lock Haven | Rider | A | A | A | B | Malcolm Ayers, Chris Carper, R. Abraham Roy, Jermaine Dwight | Chris Fischer, Shaun Foley, Chris DeLaney, Tim Wertner | Malte Bertram, Eric Ezenwanne, John Rybak, Joshua Hewitson | David Hightower, Michael Breen, Ron Moore, Matthew Millemann | 30:03:23.8550 | 10:03:21.852 | 23:03:41.3682 | 3:19.27 |
| 10. | 6. | 1. | 4. | Rider | St. Francis (Pa.) (B) | Penn State (B) | UMBC | A | B | A | A | Wilvenson Baptiste, James Burroughs, Dave Brown, Daequan Kim | Tyler Dougherty, Griffith Roberts, Matt McGarvey, Jon Eisemann | Sancho Barrett, Ryan Brennan, Connor Manley | Micah Murray, Jerome Lowery, Dontave Cowsette, Brycen Spratling | 40:03:25.792 | 21:03:33.51 | 3:19.869 | 3:22.2649 |
| 11. | 7. | 12. | 4. | Lock Haven | Pittsburgh | Rider | St. Francis (Pa.) (B) | A | A | A | A | Nathan Sweeley, Paul Stults, Caleb Getty, Richard Smith | Malcolm Ayers, Chris Carper, R. Abraham Roy, Jermaine Dwight | Malcolm Ayers, Chris Carper, R. Abraham Roy, Jermaine Dwight | Derek Henry, David Smith, Brendan Robert, Tyler Gallen | 21:03:33.51 | 3:19.27 | 30:03:23.8550 | 3:19.27 |
| 12. | 6. | 11. | 3. | St. Francis (Pa.) | Pittsburgh | Penn State | UMBC | A | B | A | B | Anthony Rusonis, Cedric Forbes, Daniel Drozdowsky, Ryan DuBois | Tyler Dougherty, Griffith Roberts, Matt McGarvey, Jon Eisemann | Micah Murray, Jerome Lowery, Dontave Cowsette, Brycen Spratling | Kevin Persson, Karl Desil, Robert Rogers, Jonathan Ocasio | 3:34.6688 | 40:03:09.6802 | 3:19.27 | 3:22.2649 |
| 13. | 1. | 8. | 10. | St. Francis (Pa.) (B) | Pittsburgh | Rider (B) | Rider (B) | B | A | A | B | Chris Fischer, Shaun Foley, Chris DeLaney, Tim Wertner | Micah Murray, Jerome Lowery, Dontave Cowsette, Brycen Spratling | Kevin Persson, Karl Desil, Robert Rogers, Jonathan Ocasio | Anthony Rusonis, Cedric Forbes, Daniel Drozdowsky, Ryan DuBois | 23:03:41.3682 | 3:19.27 | 21:03:33.51 | 40:03:09.6802 |
