| 5. | 1. | 7. | 4. | Wittenberg | Wabash | Wittenberg | DePauw | Willy Friedlander, Alton Barbehenn, Ulises Arbelo, Nat Fox | Jacob Caddick, Chris Stazinski, Bobby Thompson, Nick Boyce | Willy Friedlander, Alton Barbehenn, Ulises Arbelo, Nat Fox | Will Bond, Quinton Miller, Brian Myers, Stu Newstat | 10:30.625 | 38:10:25.6039 | 27:10:44.02 | 10:30.926 | 2951 | 10 | 442 | 69 |
| 4. | 2. | 1. | 8. | Ohio Wesleyan | Denison | Oberlin | Ohio Wesleyan | Thomas DeAscentis, Paul Livingood, Cathal Chaffe, Lance Claflin | Mitchell Keller, Zachery Cove, Jon Brachna, Ryan Keller | Willy Friedlander, Alton Barbehenn, Ulises Arbelo, Nat Fox | Willy Friedlander, Alton Barbehenn, Ulises Arbelo, Nat Fox | 31:10:36.102 | 28:10:30.035 | 27:10:44.02 | 38:10:25.6039 | 499 | 6185 | 69 | 10 |
| 5. | 3. | 6. | 6. | Ohio Wesleyan | Oberlin | DePauw | DePauw | Landon Erb, Tyler Jenkins, Nick Fowler, Nathan Madonich | Robert Moreton, Jerry Choi, Jimmy Taylor, Geno Arthur | Landon Erb, Tyler Jenkins, Nick Fowler, Nathan Madonich | Mitchell Keller, Zachery Cove, Jon Brachna, Ryan Keller | 27:10:44.02 | 10:30.625 | 10:30.926 | 27:10:44.02 | 69 | 69 | 10 | 499 |
| 2. | 4. | 8. | 7. | Allegheny | Ohio Wesleyan | Wittenberg | Wabash | Willy Friedlander, Alton Barbehenn, Ulises Arbelo, Nat Fox | Landon Erb, Tyler Jenkins, Nick Fowler, Nathan Madonich | Landon Erb, Tyler Jenkins, Nick Fowler, Nathan Madonich | Robert Moreton, Jerry Choi, Jimmy Taylor, Geno Arthur | 27:10:44.02 | 10:30.83 | 10:47.16 | 38:10:25.6039 | 00307 | 2951 | 2951 | 6185 |
| 9. | 5. | 9. | 6. | Kenyon | Allegheny | Kenyon | Wittenberg | Roy Hadfield, John Lanz, Jairaj Ranchod, Luke Hutchings-Goetz | Thomas DeAscentis, Paul Livingood, Cathal Chaffe, Lance Claflin | Thomas DeAscentis, Paul Livingood, Cathal Chaffe, Lance Claflin | Landon Erb, Tyler Jenkins, Nick Fowler, Nathan Madonich | 10:30.926 | 10:30.926 | 28:10:30.035 | 10:30.625 | - | 499 | - | 6185 |
| 7. | 6. | 3. | 9. | Kenyon | DePauw | Denison | Ohio Wesleyan | Jacob Kuntz, Chris Frierson, Austin Butler, Wade Westbrook | Will Bond, Quinton Miller, Brian Myers, Stu Newstat | Jacob Caddick, Chris Stazinski, Bobby Thompson, Nick Boyce | Roy Hadfield, John Lanz, Jairaj Ranchod, Luke Hutchings-Goetz | 10:30.926 | 31:10:36.102 | 24:11:06.75 | 10:30.926 | 442 | 00307 | 69 | 499 |
| 5. | 7. | 9. | 3. | Wabash | Kenyon | Wittenberg | Kenyon | Thomas DeAscentis, Paul Livingood, Cathal Chaffe, Lance Claflin | Willy Friedlander, Alton Barbehenn, Ulises Arbelo, Nat Fox | Robert Moreton, Jerry Choi, Jimmy Taylor, Geno Arthur | Willy Friedlander, Alton Barbehenn, Ulises Arbelo, Nat Fox | 38:10:25.6039 | 27:10:44.02 | 10:30.625 | 28:10:30.035 | 2951 | 442 | 01 | 01 |
| 4. | 8. | 1. | 7. | Allegheny | Wittenberg | Denison | Allegheny | Will Bond, Quinton Miller, Brian Myers, Stu Newstat | Jacob Kuntz, Chris Frierson, Austin Butler, Wade Westbrook | Roy Hadfield, John Lanz, Jairaj Ranchod, Luke Hutchings-Goetz | Thomas DeAscentis, Paul Livingood, Cathal Chaffe, Lance Claflin | 10:47.16 | 10:47.16 | 24:11:06.75 | 38:10:25.6039 | 01 | 01 | 01 | 01 |
| 2. | 9. | 9. | 5. | Oberlin | Wooster | DePauw | Kenyon | Robert Moreton, Jerry Choi, Jimmy Taylor, Geno Arthur | Roy Hadfield, John Lanz, Jairaj Ranchod, Luke Hutchings-Goetz | Landon Erb, Tyler Jenkins, Nick Fowler, Nathan Madonich | Jacob Caddick, Chris Stazinski, Bobby Thompson, Nick Boyce | 31:10:36.102 | 24:11:06.75 | 27:10:44.02 | 27:10:44.02 | 2951 | - | 2951 | 00307 |
