| 3. | 1. | | 3. | UMBC | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | Lock Haven | Bucknell | A | A | B | A | Ross Pirnie, Andrew Kirna, Zachary Williams, John Kirna | David Dorsey, Jimmy Daniels, Sean Macpherson, John Mascioli | David Dorsey, Jimmy Daniels, Sean Macpherson, John Mascioli | David Dorsey, Jimmy Daniels, Sean Macpherson, John Mascioli | 33:18:02.65 | 17:40.2199 | 17:40.2199 | 54:17:44.2442 |
| 4. | 2. | | 1. | UMBC | Bucknell | Bucknell | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | A | A | A | B | Henry Colby, Zack Bush, Jonathan Buytenhuys, Anson Weidner | Ross Pirnie, Andrew Kirna, Zachary Williams, John Kirna | Hassan Omar, Jonathan Luckin, Rhys Burgett, Patrick Duboyce | Sean Weidner, Mitchell Coakley, Jereamy Hall, Patrick Miller | DQ | 54:17:44.2442 | 17:40.2199 | DQ |
| 5. | 3. | 3. | | Lock Haven | UMBC | Bucknell | Lock Haven (B) | B | A | B | B | Hassan Omar, Jonathan Luckin, Rhys Burgett, Patrick Duboyce | Hassan Omar, Jonathan Luckin, Rhys Burgett, Patrick Duboyce | Hassan Omar, Jonathan Luckin, Rhys Burgett, Patrick Duboyce | Hassan Omar, Jonathan Luckin, Rhys Burgett, Patrick Duboyce | 17:40.2199 | 33:18:02.65 | 33:18:02.65 | 17:40.2199 |
| 2. | 4. | 1. | 1. | UMBC | St. Joseph's (Pa.) (B) | St. Joseph's (Pa.) (B) | Lock Haven | A | B | A | A | Henry Colby, Zack Bush, Jonathan Buytenhuys, Anson Weidner | Jack Daly, Shawn Hutchison, Will Sponaugle, Brendan Bilotta | Ross Pirnie, Andrew Kirna, Zachary Williams, John Kirna | Hassan Omar, Jonathan Luckin, Rhys Burgett, Patrick Duboyce | 54:17:44.2442 | 16:18:12.3877 | 16:18:12.3877 | 33:18:02.65 |
| 5. | 5. | 4. | 4. | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | Lock Haven | Bucknell | Lock Haven (B) | B | A | B | A | Ross Pirnie, Andrew Kirna, Zachary Williams, John Kirna | Sean Weidner, Mitchell Coakley, Jereamy Hall, Patrick Miller | David Dorsey, Jimmy Daniels, Sean Macpherson, John Mascioli | Henry Colby, Zack Bush, Jonathan Buytenhuys, Anson Weidner | 57:18:21.365 | 57:18:21.365 | 54:17:44.2442 | 17:40.2199 |
| 5. | | 1. | 5. | St. Joseph's (Pa.) (B) | Lock Haven (B) | Lock Haven (B) | UMBC | A | B | A | A | Sean Weidner, Mitchell Coakley, Jereamy Hall, Patrick Miller | Henry Colby, Zack Bush, Jonathan Buytenhuys, Anson Weidner | Hassan Omar, Jonathan Luckin, Rhys Burgett, Patrick Duboyce | Sean Weidner, Mitchell Coakley, Jereamy Hall, Patrick Miller | 54:17:44.2442 | DQ | 17:40.2199 | 33:18:02.65 |
