| 1. | 3. | York (Pa.) | Messiah | A | A | Taylor Barkdoll, Emma Rogers, Jessica DelViscio, Nicole Wasserleben | Emma Fertig, Ashlyn Stonge, Maddison Landis, Mikayla Lewin | 10:01.919 | 11:01.9429 | 10 | - |
| 2. | 2. | Juniata | Dickinson | A | B | Julia Freimuth, Yanibel Collado, Grace Alexander, Azia Kalil | Julia Freimuth, Yanibel Collado, Grace Alexander, Azia Kalil | 10:16.11 | 43:10:17.26 | 820 | 4 |
| 3. | 3. | Messiah | Juniata | A | A | Emma Fertig, Ashlyn Stonge, Maddison Landis, Mikayla Lewin | Amelia Hallock, Hannah Herzon, Laura Berman, Kyra Ramos | 43:10:17.26 | 11:28.478 | 956 | 956 |
| 4. | 2. | Dickinson | Messiah | A | A | Sofia Porras, Olivia Watson, Claire Connors, Amelia Lufrano | Sofia Porras, Olivia Watson, Claire Connors, Amelia Lufrano | 10:46.32 | 11:01.9429 | 656 | 656 |
| 5. | 2. | Alvernia | Dickinson (B) | A | A | Paige McKenna, Katelyn Schoener, Tessa Beck, Julia Malpass | Sofia Porras, Olivia Watson, Claire Connors, Amelia Lufrano | 11:01.9429 | 43:10:17.26 | 4 | - |
| 6. | 3. | Dickinson (B) | Dickinson (B) | B | A | Amelia Hallock, Hannah Herzon, Laura Berman, Kyra Ramos | Amelia Hallock, Hannah Herzon, Laura Berman, Kyra Ramos | 11:28.478 | 10:16.11 | - | 820 |
